Howard Deutch's film of a script by teen movie emperor John Hughes plays like every other John Hughes teen rom com. Molly Ringwald falls in love with a guy who has his faults while Duckie whizzes about as the prince of loveable quirk. The bad bitches at school are uber nasty and cad-leader is mean as mustard. Prince Blane is flawless and flavourless (but that smile!) and Molly is a cut-out nice teen. This is a Hughes film the way that Poltergeist is a Spielberg film: different directorial bylines can barely offer leaks around the template.
The opening credits scene might be one of those leaks. It shows a garbage truck clearing the lanes of the bad neighbourhood while a sanitised remix of the title track chugs along like it was Huey Lewis and the News. Elsewhere there are posters of The Smiths in an indy record shop, a sprinkling of UK post punk tunes under the dialogue and new wave styles lifted from the shelves of Wal-Mart. When young blokes in London wore pork pie hats it's because they were into Ska and they stopped doing it in about 1981. These yainkee copycats with their formless '70s haircuts just look like their dads. Because she's the star, the sole character who dresses with a sense of her own style is Andie herself and it's curiously along the lines of contemporary op shop deluxe and so on to hipster girls from decades after this.
The Psychedelic Furs' thunderous and growling anthem from 1981 is wearing the same kind of clothes. Both elements are not the influence of the more concentrated and popping UK originators, they are AM radio distillations. However, this only serves to render the culture on show authentic. Well, it would if there were any hints that it was intentional rather than offered as edgy. And this is hardly the fault of the film itself. All American teen movies did exactly the same thing, not just Hughes'.
Why does any of this matter? Because, as rom coms go, this film is very soft soap. The romance that had been treated with some depth on previous Hughes outings, is threatened by barely consequential opposition. The weird sister alpha chicks never rise to the occasion of a Carrie like prank and Andie is hardly so quirky that she's an outsider. The comedy causes nary a ripple and the ending happens that way because it was always going to.
Molly Ringwald delivers a fine and natural performance. Harry Dean Stanton dignifies every scene he's in as a wasting good dad ruled by regret. James Spader plays his physical perfection against type to grab as much nuance as he can from his bad guy character. Jon Cryer is never not irritating as the cute sidekick. And Andrew McCarthy. Who ever thought Andrew McCarthy was star material? He's a sugarless marshmallow with a winsome smile that should have run out of puff at Class and left by the dishes to see how long he'd hold shape. There's just nothing there.
But does there have to be? This film was made to sell a consumer lifestyle to teenagers. After getting out of this, they could go and mall themselves with suit jackets with pre-rolled sleeves in crayon colours, or big flouncy hair. There must have been genuinely stylish enclaves in America at the time but this film is not about nor for them, it's for the kids whose pocket money was more like a salary. These kids who were in primary school when the original Pretty in Pink was released might well have considered themselves blessed with a cultural miracle at having such a mass of pre-earned culture at such accessible outlets. This film is a sales catalogue and doesn't really pretend it's much else.
John Hughes secured his place in cinema history by creating a kind of teenager who was both complex and marketable. He didn't invent needledrops in movies but his movies' needledrops introduced a consumer base with the conspicuous soundtrack album, on a higher plane than a plain compilation and featured high style cover art from the screen. He used his audience's identification to air feature length commercials for a modular retail version of Reagan's America. It's not just the assaultive makeover scene in Breakfast Club that makes me wince, it's the constant insidious citizenship education sleazing all the way through it. Pretty in Pink is just a budget model. Didn't biuy it then. Don't buy it now.






