It's the complications that make this supernatural gaslighting tale nudge a little over the mass of off the shelf supernatural tales cramming the horror section of the VoD services. The people next door are being taken over by the witch but they also know how to appear normal when needed. Ben's broken wrist came from an impulsive theft and escape attempt so he has a history as a troubled teen which diminishes his credibility as a witness to atrocity. The more he has to report and investigate the more he has to trust an increasingly hostile field.
John-Paul Howard in the central role gives us a relatable teenager. Bright enough to understand the signs of foul play but sexually eager enough to miss sight of a trick being played on him and philosophy enough for us to see how much of a sport he is about it. This is important as while the film as a whole progresses without a great deal to offer beyond a standard genre outing without the warmth of this character we'd probably just hit pause and get back to it some time down the track if at all.
But while the stakes could be higher and the tension tighter The Wretched turns out to be a perfectly fine genre outing that will engage both the genre vets and casual tourists. Even the sequel wink at the end has just enough cleverness to it that we might not even mind if there is another one. As well there might be given the purpose-built evil figure that is flat enough to be malleable for future outings with minds as or more creative than here. Giving the dough a little extra time to rise? You could do worse.
Hired from Apple movies.